Options: 10 NEW Criteria for Software Purchasing

A survey of Accounting Software Buyers, by Deloitte & Touche, has gotten a lot of traction; both on its own and via other publications and bloggers; two sources are referenced below.

http://www.accountingsoftwarenews.com/reseller/secret7.htm

http://www.basi-usa.com/attachments/top10reasons.pdf

In reviewing the Top Ten criteria, I tend to agree with the conclusions of Lillian Aaron from BASI, a business software solutions provider in Austin, TX. She suggests that – “One would think second-time buyers would be ‘smarter’, if for no other reason than they have the experience first-time buyers lack. It stands to reason their rankings would be a better guide to what really matters when researching accounting system options.”  However, I couldn’t get out of my head my own experiences – both beginner and experienced software buyers make purchase decisions they later regret. I then reflected on the following quote:

“I have learned the novice can often see things that the expert overlooks. All that is necessary is not to be afraid of making mistakes, or of appearing naive.” – Abraham Maslow

So which is it – Criteria A or Criteria B? Are there C and D lists too? In fact, buyer criteria comes in many forms and varies on circumstances. Therefore, I’m convinced that more emphasis should be placed on the process itself, and less on factors that are hard to control. So…below is my attempt at Criteria C: 

  1. Do I need what I’m attempting to buy? Why? Is there ROI?
  2. Do I need this now, or can we operate effectively as we are? Why now?
  3. Should I research and search for a new system on my own, or do I need help?
  4. When I narrow my options, how will I choose between the best options?
  5. Will my people embrace or resist change? What will I do to influence acceptance?
  6. What factors should be considered, both short and long term?
  7. What are my options – buy (existing funds), borrow (financing), grant (nonprofit), rent (Saas subscription-based model), leverage (existing system used by a partner entity), etc.?
  8. Who can I call – people that I trust – that went through a similar decision-making process?
  9. Do I have the infrastructure to support such a change – i.e. someone that will champion and manage the project, IT equipment and bandwidth, well-defined procedures, etc.
  10. When progress is made, how will I know that I made the right decision (success factors)?

 Do you see the difference? Trust me, if you ask a vendor for references, you’ll get them and they’ll likely be amazing! So how helpful is that? If you negotiate hard and get the price you want, does not ensure that you’ve made the right choice? Not necessarily. What if the vendor/product has a strong market reputation and has been servicing clients for 10+ years? Well, unfortunately, we all likely know of folks that used that as key decision criteria and still found themselves disappointed. So, I suggest that you look much deeper inside before looking externally. It may be that you’ll surprise yourself with what you find and identify viable options you had not yet considered. In the end, trust yourself, the process, and the team that helps you along the way.

If I can help as a resource, Contact me so we can explore the possibilities.

Image credit:  © Helder Almeida – Fotolia.com

Share

Small Nonprofit Starter Solutions & Resources

“Those who are lifting the world upward and onward are those who encourage more than criticize.” – Elizabeth Harrison

This quote fits the nonprofit community so well. In fact, many nonprofits begin as a result of a strong passion to bring about change, a.k.a. a Mission. However, once this passion results in the creation of an organization, reality often sets in soon after that – “OMG, I’m actually running a business!” In fact, many startup nonprofit founders aren’t the most business savvy folks; they typically just have a BIG heart and lots of compassion for those in need. This isn’t criticism by the way, but it is reality…and that’s OK; the world needs more of this. Of course, this is where a strong board of advisors helps!

As such, I’ve created a categorized list of small business solutions and online resources that is designed to help these big-hearted folks start off on the right foot with affordable, viable business software systems. Of course, this is not a comprehensive list, but for the most part these references represent many of the systems that I either see nonprofits using or know that they should at least be considering.

Office Suite

 Website/Blog

 Data Backup, Storage

 Donor Database

 Resources

  • TechSoup Blog, @TechSoup
  • GuideStar Blogs, @GuideStar
  • NTEN Blog, @NTENOrg
  • IdealWare, @IdealWare
  • LinkedIN Groups
    • Nonprofit Professionals Forum
    • Nonprofit Technology Network
    • Some of my fav Twitter follows:
      • @501Connect (St. Louis, MO area)
      • @GreenlightsATX (Austin, Tx area)
      • @daveiam, @NPFilm (Austin, Tx area)
      • @fdncenter
      • @npquarterly

This list is virtually endless – i.e. Collaboration, App Store tools, Accounting, Project Management, Grants Management, Webcasts, Phone systems, and so on.

What I want to leave you with is this…as you share your passion with your relevant community, and then realize that there’s a business to run too, then be sure and 1) create a plan, 2) ask for help, 3) and document your needs by priority level. You may need to invest some startup capital early on, but if you’re committed to the long-term life of the organization then this investment will return dividends many times throughout your history.

If I can help as a resource, Contact me so we can explore the possibilities. All the best in “doing good.”

Image credit: © UgputuLf FT – Fotolia.com

Share

Questions to Ask Before Signing Software Purchase Contracts

Ok, so you’ve done the hard work and feel like you found a software system that meets your needs. Now comes the dreaded step of reviewing pricing and signing the contract agreement. Do you feel comfortable with the jargon? What is this line, and why is it so much? Are these all fixed costs, or are some of these costs recurring? What does “licensing” really mean? These are all good questions, and ones that you may not feel comfortable with. After all, you buy a software system for your business only every few years. It’s ok. Take a deep breath and consider the following tips by Software Advice, an online software search service based in Austin, TX.

http://www.softwareadvice.com/articles/accounting/9-key-questions-to-ask-about-your-erp-software-license-1042611/

My  Additional Comments:

1) if including “add-ons” in your purchase, be sure to understand who is responsible for supporting the product. Also, verify that the add-on vendor is “licensed” with the main product vendor so that when new versions are released the add-on vendor has time to confirm compatibility with the changes.

2) Maintenance – many buyers don’t realize that some software companies allow for reduced pricing is multi-year contracts are purchased in advance. If, as a buyer, you can swing this in the budget than you may save some $ here.

3) Support – if buying through an authorized VAR (value added reseller) then check to see if they too offer support services. This may cost extra, so consider this in your budget, but if they are local and responsive then you may want to go this route since they setup your database and know you personally.

4) Concurrent login – lots of questions needed here. I know some products that count each login per module against the user license count; even if it’s the same user!

If you chose to do your own software search, and you’ve made it this far but identify with the concerns I illustrated above, then reach out to me for assistance. Otherwise, take your time and ask lots of questions before signing any contract agreement. Also, to the extent possible, make sure the contract references the things you feel are important, because you never know when issues will arise and you may need to rely on this agreement to protect your investment.

As always, let me know what you’ve come across in the contracts that you’ve had to negotiate, and how what you asked before agreeing to move forward. Thanks!

Image credit: © Bruce Shippee – Fotolia.com

Share

Which Tech Skills Help Accountants Land Jobs?

Below is a link to an article by Hunter Richards, Accounting Market Analysts with Software Advice in Austin, TX.

http://www.softwareadvice.com/articles/accounting/which-tech-skills-help-accountants-land-jobs/

My feeling is that this excellent post has two very specific audiences. First, job seeks – accounting grads for sure – who are all looking for any way possible to create differentiation. Also, hopefully, employers see this as a way to creatively weed through the volume of resumes by including specifics in job descriptions – i.e. “we are looking for candidates experienced with XYZ business software application.”

I have a related idea…should software companies offer a service to its clients of posting client job openings? Personally, I think so. Do you see this happening? If not, do you think this is a good idea?

I want to personally thank Hunter for his research effort and creative analysis of a timely, relevant topic.

Share

How to Compare Accounting Software for Small Businesses

Small Business article by Sheila Shanker via The Houston Chronicle – http://smallbusiness.chron.com/compare-accounting-software-small-business-853.html

I came across this article recently and found it of value. The four steps that Ms. Shanker outlines are spot on. It’s not that there’s anything revolutionary within, but rather that she begins with the most important step – Make a list. Her four steps include – Make a list, Budget, Research & Compare, and Review & Test. Be sure to make special note of her advice to prioritize your list; great point! Note: You don’t have to share the priorities with software vendors.

I spoke this week at Greenlights for Nonprofit Success in Austin, TX. It was a rewarding experience. The attendees were responsive throughout and genuinely interested in becoming good stewards of their nonprofit resources – people and funding sources for sure. I’ll speak again next month with the Texas Society of Women Accountants. Although this audience will be quite different the content of the software search process remains essentially the same.

A number of folks I come across ask me, “So what types of software does Solution Explorers help organization’s search for?” My answer is…”it doesn’t really matter.” (relatively speaking) In fact, an organization this is looking to purchase a small business accounting software should follow the same core steps as the company that is exploring ERP software that impacts multiple divisions.  In other words, Solution Explorers provides a disciplined process, as opposed to focusing on a specific type of solution. The core steps that Solution Explorers follows are outlines as:

  1. Discovery – Needs Analysis (internal discovery)
  2. Discovery – Solution Exploration (external discovery)
  3. Selection – Short list, Presentations, Negotiation, Decision

Please understand, many incremental steps occur before, in between, and even after these steps but regardless of the software your business is searching for the core steps remain the same. Whatever you do, however, don’t skip or even scale back the time and effort required to “make a list”; and I would add…documentation!

Additionally, have you considered audio and/or video recording the process? As you meet with your internal team I recommend documenting the process via audio and/or video. Why? Once you engage with software vendors the water can get muddy real quick. Therefore, by following this simple tip you will have documentation to refer to that will help keep the project on track and, possibly more important, keep you in control of the buying process.

Good luck with your search efforts. Contact us if we can be of service in any way.

Image credit: © Tombaky – Fotolia.com

Share

Software Selection Criteria

Threaded throughout various posts within my Blog history are tips on what to look for in software worth investing in. Because criteria are different for every buyer it’s virtually impossible to truly develop a global list. But like many things in life and business there are some things to look for that should be considered regardless of specific business requirements.

Therefore, in this post, I want to share a standard criteria list, a few thoughts, and receive from you criteria that you deem important before making a selection and writing a check.

User-friendliness – often defined by # of clicks, first impressions, user interface (GUI)
Ease-of-Setup (aka, implementation) – reduces consulting costs, quick up-time and ROI
Accessibility – can we get to data easily and when we need it?
Scalable (grow as we grow) – modules, addons, customizability
Affordability – only the buyer can truly define this requirement
User-defined Reporting – ODBC compliant, report writer, compliance
Security and Reliability – protect data, minimize downtime
Support (reliable, experienced) – user forums, knowledgebase, webcasts, upgrades

Buyers need to choose software that suits their specific needs and system requirements. This needs to be done carefully as a wrong choice would result in increased work and possibly a bad investment. Looking over your shoulder or feeling regret post-purchase are feelings no decision maker wants to experience. Often, a software purchase leaves folks feeling – betrayed, misled, manipulated, etc. Establishing clearly defined criteria, as simple as those above or granular to your specific system requirements, takes a lot of time and skill but is absolutely essential for good stewardship with business revenue or donor dollars.

What do you look forward when trying to find software that meets your needs and budget?

How do you prioritize your selection criteria?

What did you learn from your last software selection, purchase?

Image credit: © Iuliia Tsvietkova – Fotolia.com

Share

From the Software Buyer’s Mindset

The road junction and blue sky and green grassEarlier this week I shared Blog post details from Software Advice in Austin, TX regarding the ongoing debate between best-of-breed versus integrated suite solutions. Let me now share some brief thoughts on the question that was posed – “How do you deal with choosing between all-in-one versus best-of-breed?” – for which there is really no concrete answer; i.e. each buyer has to determine this based on their unique needs and circumstances. However, since the article addressed this question thoroughly from the solution perspective, I want to discuss this from the buyer’s mindset.

As the article states, there are advantages and disadvantages to each solution approach, and I can validate this because I’ve worked for companies that marketed each type of offering. Admittedly, I’ve also sold solutions while arguing for and against each position. The “right” decision really is contextual.

In the past, I’ve witnessed clients (loyal ones at that) purchase solutions from new vendors when my company could have provided the very thing they sought. Why do they do this? Well, in many cases they simply didn’t consider calling the existing vendor. Weird, I know. Also, this situation may occur when departments fail to communicate – i.e. Development wants fundraising software for their nonprofit but fails to inquire with Accounting about what system they use. This is a mistake. Communication is vital when making decisions and investing critical funds. To be fair, some ‘integrated suite solution’ vendors focus so heavily on the “strong” product that they poorly educate clients on the complimentary applications that are also available; yet another costly mistake.

Conversely, I’ve seen organizations reach out ONLY to the existing vendor, find what they want but fail to compare for various reasons; oftentimes for fear of “offending” the vendor. This is crazy! Just because I own a Chevrolet does this mean that every family member should have one too? No. I’m a believer that software buyer’s should intentionally consider many options during the decision cycle. By doing so buyer’s become well-informed regarding their options and good stewards of their decision process and funding resources.

In summary, buyers should approach this decision with an open mind and position themselves to negotiate a purchase that provides them the right solution for their unique needs. Some other considerations may be – system utilization by end users, existing technology infrastructure, locality of service resources, and many others. Sorry, but there’s no easy way to sugar-coat this, buying software takes time and requires skill. Therefore, document your needs, challenge vendors with probing questions, and negotiating hard for the best price.

Good luck in your search. If you have a strong opinion one way or the other regarding best-of-breed vs. integrated suite solutions then post a comment.

Image credit: © rufar – Fotolia.com

Share

Fork-in-a-Road: Best-of-Breed or Integrated Suite Solution?

The road junction and blue sky and green grass

Source: Software Advice Blog, http://www.softwareadvice.com/articles/uncategorized/best-of-breed-or-integrated-suite-10-questions-to-consider-1050610/

The 10 questions suggested by the author are:

  • Are your needs for the new application really that specialized, or can they be met by your ERP vendor’s (potentially) broader offering?
  • Do you really need the systems integrated, or are you OK with two standalone systems?
  • Does your ERP vendor offer (or come close enough to offering) what you need?
  • Do you have the IT resources necessary to perform a complete integration?
  • Are the near-term hurdles of implementing a suite or best-of-breed system justifiable for long-term business improvements, or are they prohibitive?
  • How truly integrated is the integrated suite vendor’s offering?
  • Is the ERP vendor’s solution close to a best-of-breed system?
  • What is the long-term viability of the best-of-breed vendor?
  • Will the ERP vendor give you such a significant price discount that it offsets the sacrifice in functionality?
  • Does the new applications category (i.e. CRM) merit a different deployment model (i.e. SaaS) than your back-office ERP system (i.e. on-premise)?

Question: How do you deal with choosing between all-in-one versus best-of-breed? Answering this without regard specifically to software is perfectly fine.

Image credit: © rufar – Fotolia.com

Share

The Nonprofit Buyer

One of the greatest challenges encountered by those seeking to find software for their business needs is that those within the organization are not “professional” buyers. Think about it…the typical business replaces its core business systems – accounting, CRM/Fundraising, HR/Payroll, Client Management, etc. – about every 5-7 years. So, the opportunity, or even value in, creating a documented process for buying software isn’t very high; much less making this a skill requirement in someone’s job description.

This industry-wide problem is certainly a key reason for Solution Explorers’ existence. However, there are other software buyer resources available and we all can learn from one another. Two recent resources that I’ve encountered are – Andrew Urban, author of The Nonprofit Buyer and Edwin Henrikson. I’m currently reading Andrew’s book and have found valuable insights that every software buyer, even seller, can benefit from. As Andrew was advertising the book release via the LinkedIN Group – Nonprofit Technology Network – Edwin posted some insightful comments; of which I now want to share with you for consideration. I hope you find these of value as I did.

Comments by: Edwin Henrikson (re-posted with permission)

My key points regarding technology purchases are as follows…

1) Requirements: writing the requirements are the first step. The largest barrier is the staff may or may not know all the “rules” as defined by the funder(s) or their own agency. Many if not most staff operate on what I’ve come to call “tribal knowledge.” Many classic re-engineering issues come into play here, like “paving the deer trail” rather than building a highway.
2) Implementation: The capacity/ability of staff to adjust to the new technology or system is often over-looked. Agency culture with regards to change is an essential element to success. Also, simply having the talent and time to adopt the new system (train, use and improve) is often a huge barrier. With new systems often comes new skill requirements. Salesforce.com has found this issue as a critical barrier to donating systems to nonprofits. Complex Donor management systems and accounting systems also fall victim to this barrier.
3) Scales of Efficiency: many nonprofits can’t afford professional and complex solutions. However, even if the culture and talent of the staff can adopt a new system, simply having enough staff to manage the system well and train others is often a barrier. One way to overcome this barrier is to leverage shared systems or partner with other nonprofits in the area to pool resources.
4) Start Easy: Don’t overlook continuous improvement over the radical forklift replacement approach. Two actions can go a long way to freeing up capacity to then engage in major improvements – start with the basics, and consider process simplifications.
5) Technology is only part of the answer: I often tell my clients that any service is comprised of systems, people and process. All three must work together or the service suffers. I’ve seen many agencies take on changes in systems with no real consideration to how processes must change and how staff (people) will be impacted. This point ties into number 2 above. The agency can then be capacity starved to align the people and processes with the new system.

Note: Comments above were edited above as appropriate for purposes of this blog. Click here to view the full details of the originating LinkedIN post.

Image credit: © Roman Milert – Fotolia.com

Share